Lost value answer, past the menu
Call(855) 589-7222

The 17c Formula for Diminished Value

Many insurers estimate your car's drop in resale value after a crash with a simple tool they call 17c.

The 17c diminished value equals the car's worth before the crash, times 10%, times the damage multiplier, times the mileage multiplier.

Work out your car's 17c figure

The 17c formula gives you a dollar amount for diminished value. After a crash shows up on your car's history, the resale price you can get drops: that drop is diminished value. This loss continues even after repair work that is done well.

The 17c Formula in Three Steps

Every 17c diminished value calculator, ours included, works from three inputs: the car's pre-accident value, how serious the damage was, and the mileage. The word multiplier describes a figure between 0 and 1 that you apply in a multiplication.

  1. Calculate the base loss. In a price guide like Kelley Blue Book or NADA (another source for used-car pricing), find the car's worth right before the crash. Take 10% of that value. The 17c formula sets this base loss as its maximum: what an insurer actually offers you is a separate question.
  2. Apply the damage multiplier. On the damage table, pick the row that describes your car. The scale runs from 1.00 when the main metal frame was badly harmed down to 0.00 if the frame was not damaged. Multiply the base loss by the number from that row.
  3. Apply the mileage multiplier. Pick the row in the table that fits the miles on your car the day of the crash. The multiplier starts at 1.00 when the car has fewer than 20,000 miles and reaches 0.00 at 100,000 miles or more. Take what you have from step 2 and multiply it by that mileage number. The result you get is the 17c figure.

Table of Damage Multipliers

Damage level in the 17c tableMultiplier
Severe structural damage1.00
Major damage to structure and panels0.75
Moderate damage to structure and panels0.50
Minor damage to structure and panels0.25
No structural damage or replaced panels0.00

Now check the lowest row. When the frame stayed untouched, the 17c outcome is $0 no matter how high the repair bill ran. That $0 figure is only what the 17c formula produces. The actual value of your car may have fallen anyway. Even after fixing outer panels like doors, fenders and bumpers, the amount a buyer will pay can still drop. The market range we see for that sort of damage falls between 2% and 5% of the car's worth. You will find an explanation of that range in our guide about calculating diminished value.

Table of Mileage Multipliers

Miles at the time of the crashMultiplier
0 to 19,9991.00
20,000 to 39,9990.80
40,000 to 59,9990.60
60,000 to 79,9990.40
80,000 to 99,9990.20
100,000 or more0.00

The origin of the formula is State Farm v. The settlement order for Mabry (Georgia, 2001) contains this in paragraph 17, section C. The tables are printed by a car research firm, J.D. Power. The worked example comes to us from Kelley Blue Book, which is a used-car pricing guide.

Not every insurer uses the same mileage rows. An article in a law school journal shows a different scale that one lawsuit used. That scale applies 0.9 at a mileage of 10,000.

Diminished Value Formula 17c: A Worked Example

The worked example that follows is from Kelley Blue Book. Before it was hit, the car had 30,000 miles on it and a value of $25,000. Imagine a collision where the frame and outside panels are harmed to a moderate degree.

  1. Start with the base loss: 10% of $25,000 comes to $2,500.
  2. Next, for the damage: multiply $2,500 by 0.50 and you get $1,250.
  3. For the miles: take $1,250 and multiply it by 0.80 to arrive at $1,000.

The claims person at the insurance company, called the adjuster, would probably start from that $1,000. Changing just one number can move the outcome a great deal. Consider what happens when the car shows 100,000 miles. The multiplier for mileage then moves to 0.00. The 17c number you land on is $0.

Now consider what buyers in the real market pay. For a car with moderate damage, our calculator shows a loss of 5% to 12% of the car's worth. That range comes from Property Damage Pros, a Utah law office with certified appraisers. With a car of that same $25,000 value, the range turns out to be $1,250 to $3,000. To put your 17c number next to your market range, use our diminished value calculator.

Open the diminished value calculator

Repair estimate and car value guide on an adjuster desk, the inputs of the 17c formula

Why the 17c Formula Tends to Lowball

Three things push the result downward in this formula.

  • The 10% cap. A nearly new car tops out at 10% of its value no matter the damage, yet Property Damage Pros places the loss from frame damage in the 15% to 30% range of the car’s worth.
  • The cut based on mileage. The number drops to zero once the car passes 100,000 miles. That rule led State Farm to apply a 0% mileage multiplier for one driver in the Tiller case. The formula returned $0 for that driver's lost value.
  • The cut based on damage. The damage multiplier sits at 0.00 when the frame stays untouched. Yet Carfax reports that a used car with a damage history on its record falls roughly $500 in average retail price.

A 17c Offer for One Driver: $48.76

Real offers from insurers show you how the process plays out. A federal appeals court heard Tiller v. State Farm, where the damage to the driver's car reached $6,000. In its letter, State Farm's breakdown of the 17c offer went as follows:

  1. Value: take the NADA guide price for the car before the crash, cut it by 90%, and you are left with a 10% base loss.
  2. Damage cut: after that, they removed another 30%.
  3. Mileage cut: next, they stripped off an additional 11%.
  4. Offer: the check they sent was for $48.76. The driver thought the amount was too low and did not cash the check.

Drivers said that 17c was designed to keep the numbers small. The appeals court left that question unanswered. It resolved the case on separate issues and said it would not rule on the formula's fairness.

People who work in the field also do not like it. The law school journal Boston University Law Review reports that no solid reasoning supported the choice of numbers. The national group of state insurance regulators publishes the NAIC Journal of Insurance Regulation; its 2023 piece describes the Georgia formula as flawed. An insurance company can also offer less than what 17c gives. A Kelley Blue Book editor arrived at $650 to $715 for her own car; The amount Liberty Mutual offered her was $400.

How to Push Back on a Low 17c Offer

Think of the 17c amount as the insurer's first move, not the final one. You can measure the loss through other approaches, even if this diminished value formula remains the most recognized. The insurance company's point of view is the only one you get from a 17c formula calculator.

  1. Get a market appraisal set up. An appraiser, a trained professional, figures out what cars are worth. Kelley Blue Book advises using a certified appraiser for a large claim: that is a car appraiser with an official credential. The appraisal puts a value on your repaired car from real sales, not from a table of prices. Our appraisal guide lays out the cost.
  2. Compare it to the repair bill. The NAIC paper points out that the loss is often close to 10% to 20% of what the repairs cost. If the 17c number you receive sits well under that range, put that in a written note to them.
  3. Put your demand in writing. A demand letter is a short note you send to ask the insurance company for a set payment. Send it with your number, the appraisal, and the repair paperwork. Our demand letter template completes itself from the details you give it.
  4. Check what your state says. State law sets whether you can file the claim and the deadline you have. Look at the state rules table. If the insurance company will not raise its offer, talk to a lawyer.

Is the 17c Formula Georgia Law?

No. It started from a Georgia court case, but the state never turned it into a rule. On December 1, 2008, the Georgia insurance commissioner put out an official notice saying the department never adopted a formula for losses of this type. Depending on just one formula may be wrong, the notice also says.

The formula spread anyway. Many insurance companies lean on it, according to Carfax. In the federal case, the drivers were struck by people covered by State Farm. For at least two of those claims, State Farm applied 17c to work out the payment.

The Origin of the 17c Formula: State Farm v. Mabry

The formula began with a Georgia lawsuit, State Farm v. Mabry, a case started by State Farm's own Georgia customers. On November 28, 2001, the Supreme Court of Georgia held that a crash can reduce a car's worth even after it is fixed. Figuring out that loss and covering the repairs fell to State Farm. The lower court had said the claims must go through “an appropriate methodology and procedure,” and the higher court agreed with that ruling.

After that, State Farm's response was to create a method of its own. A federal appeals court explains that the Georgia trial court approved it by issuing an order on March 6, 2002. The order put the method in paragraph 17, section C: that is where the label 17c comes from.

Why did they use a formula? The lawsuit included thousands of State Farm customers. Examining each vehicle individually would have required too much time and money. As that same law school journal reports, the deal that closed the case, called a settlement, turned to a formula instead.

Questions about your claim? Call to speak with someone who works on diminished value claims.

Call (855) 589-7222