Lost value answer, past the menu
Call(855) 589-7222

What Is Diminished Value?

After a crash a car loses resale value, even with good repairs: here is who pays for it.

What it means
The resale loss after a crash, even when the fix was solid
Typical loss on the market
CarGurus found a range from 3% to 12%
Carfax average drop
About $500, and $2,100 when the damage is serious
Which party normally covers the cost?
The insurer of the driver who caused the crash
Repaired car on a used car lot, where diminished value shows up in the price

Drivers who ask what is diminished value usually have a repaired car and a low offer from an adjuster. In plain terms, here is the idea. A car loses resale value because buyers are aware of the crash, even after a good repair.

The Diminished Value of a Car After a Repair

The Washington insurance regulator puts it plainly. The market value of your car before the accident, minus its value after repairs, is what diminished value captures. Your repair bill pays for the parts and the work. The mark left on your car's record is not covered by the repair bill.

Courts and lawyers sometimes call the same loss diminution in value. The words differ, but the idea is the same. The shop gave your car back looking good, yet a dealer will offer you less for it now.

The Three Types, Including Inherent Diminished Value

Kelley Blue Book and J.D. Power both describe three kinds of loss. Each kind begins at a different point in the repair process.

  • Inherent: the loss that follows from the crash being listed on the history report. Even a perfect repair does not stop this type, and it is the focus of most claims.
  • Repair-related: the extra loss caused by poor repair work. The price drops further when a door will not shut right or the paint fails to match.
  • Immediate: the loss present before any repair starts. The loss matters when you sell or trade in the car before the damage gets fixed. Insurers seldom receive claims of this kind.

Inherent loss is the type of diminished value car owners ask about most. It is also the hardest type to notice, because the car looks fine.

Why a Car Loses Worth Following an Accident

After an accident, a car's diminished value starts with the information on its history report. Anyone shopping for a used car can check that report before buying. A crash on the record gives a buyer a reason to make a lower offer. A car known to have been damaged draws a lower price from buyers, the Insurance Information Institute reports. A repair that meets top standards does not alter that reality.

Buyers check for damage because it is so common. Carfax reports that about 1 in 4 used cars listed for sale have been damaged. That same source reported that 25% of owners who have a damaged car list it for sale within a year. A clean history report helps sell a car today, and a crash record takes that advantage away.

How Much Does an Accident Devalue a Car?

The exact amount varies from car to car. A large study by CarGurus looked at 2 million listings. Forbes reported that, in general, cars with a crash history sell for 3% to 12% less than similar cars with no crash history.

Carfax gives the loss in dollar amounts. According to its guide to diminished value, the average retail price of a used car drops by about $500. That figure rises to $2,100 when the damage is severe. A different Carfax page puts severe damage at $1,700, so treat both numbers as rough estimates.

The kind of damage makes the biggest difference. An appraiser group, Property Damage Pros, reports that dents and bumpers cut value by 2% to 5%. The loss rises to 15% to 30% if the frame or subframe is bent. The age of the car also plays a role. The Insurance Information Institute notes that replacing old parts with new ones may increase an older car's value after a repair. Our calculator gives a range for your car once you answer three questions.

Diminished Value vs Depreciation

With age and more miles, every car loses value. That drop is called depreciation. Kelley Blue Book says a new car loses about 30% in its first two years, followed by 8% to 12% each year after that. You receive no money for that loss. It happens whether you have a crash or not.

A crash takes away even more value on top of the normal depreciation. Kelley Blue Book puts it the same way: a crash strips value beyond what aging already costs. You can seek payment for that extra loss from the other driver's insurer through a claim. Diminished value vs depreciation comes down to a single question. Think about what the car would be worth if the crash had not occurred, and then ask if it would still be this much less.

Diminished Value Insurance: Does Insurance Cover It?

The money usually comes from the other party's insurance company. The Insurance Information Institute notes that if someone else hit you, you should receive this payment in every state except Michigan. Liability coverage from the at-fault driver provides the money. A third-party claim is the name for a claim against that insurer.

Your own policy handles things differently. Filing a claim under your own policy makes it a first-party claim, and this loss is not covered by most collision policies. A study published in the NAIC Journal of Insurance Regulation reviewed the rules in each state. Only Georgia has a clear rule that permits drivers to seek this loss on their own policy, the study determined. Roughly half the states let you use uninsured motorist protection to make a claim when the responsible driver has no insurance.

Whichever path you choose, you still need to prove the loss. What your state allows is shown in our state rules table. The claim steps walk you through asking for the payment.

What are the questions drivers have?

Is it worthwhile to file a diminished value claim?

A newer car, low miles and real damage make a claim pay off most often. The newer the car and the lower its miles, the better your chance of payment, Kelley Blue Book notes. A high-mileage older car may lose almost nothing.

How Much Value Does a Car Lose With an Accident Shown on Carfax?

Carfax data puts the average retail price drop at about $500. That figure rises to $2,100 when the damage is severe. Your final loss depends on the vehicle itself, its mileage, and the severity of the damage.

Can You Claim Diminished Value for Hail Damage?

Rarely. No other driver caused hail, so the repair is paid by the comprehensive part of your own policy, as the Colorado insurance regulator explains. That makes it a claim on your own policy, and most policies exclude lost value. Georgia is the clear exception, so read your policy before you ask.

Can You Claim Diminished Value With a Leased Vehicle?

The process is harder. The leasing company owns the car and is therefore the harmed party, Kelley Blue Book points out. Contact the leasing company first and let it pursue the claim.

If the Car Is a Total Loss, Does Diminished Value Apply?

In most cases, no. The insurer must hand over the car’s actual cash value following a total loss, the Washington insurance regulator explains. That number often comes from what cars like yours sell for nearby. There is no repaired vehicle left to suffer a drop in resale value.

Questions about your claim? Call to speak with someone who works on diminished value claims.

Call (855) 589-7222