Diminished Value Laws in All 50 States and DC
For each state the table shows deadlines, fault rules and the two claim types: one against the other driver and one on your own policy.
- States that allow a claim against the other driver's insurer (2 of them by statute)
- 29
- States where that claim is likely, but no court has settled it
- 16
- States that allow that claim only in limited situations
- 6
- States where your own policy can cover it (Georgia; Oregon, with a condition)
- 2
- Deadline to sue, depending on the state
- 2 to 10 years
All 50 States and DC at a Glance
| State | File a claim with the other driver's insurance company | File a claim on your own insurance policy | Time limit for filing a lawsuit. | Fault rule | Minimum property damage liability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Likely, not settled | No, courts ruled | 6 years | Contributory negligence | $25,000 |
| Alaska | Likely, not settled | Not settled | 2 years | Pure comparative | $25,000 |
| Arizona | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Pure comparative | $15,000 |
| Arkansas | Yes, by statute | Not settled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| California | Likely, not settled | Policy decides | 3 years | Pure comparative | $15,000 |
| Colorado | Yes | Policy decides | 3 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $15,000 |
| Connecticut | Yes | Policy decides | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Delaware | Likely, not settled | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| District of Columbia | Yes | Not settled | 3 years | Contributory negligence | $10,000 |
| Florida | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| Georgia | Yes | Yes | 4 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Hawaii | Likely, not settled | Not settled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
| Idaho | Likely, not settled | Policy decides | 3 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $15,000 |
| Illinois | Yes | No, courts ruled | 5 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
| Indiana | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Iowa | Yes | Not settled | 5 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $15,000 |
| Kansas | Yes | Policy decides | 2 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Kentucky | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Pure comparative | $25,000 |
| Louisiana | Yes, by statute | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Maine | Likely, not settled | No, courts ruled | 6 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Maryland | Yes | Policy decides | 3 years | Contributory negligence | $15,000 |
| Massachusetts | Limited | No, courts ruled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $30,000 |
| Michigan | Limited | No, courts ruled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| Minnesota | Likely, not settled | Policy decides | 6 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| Mississippi | Yes | Policy decides | 3 years | Pure comparative | $25,000 |
| Missouri | Yes | Policy decides | 5 years | Pure comparative | $25,000 |
| Montana | Likely, not settled | Policy decides | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
| Nebraska | Limited | Not settled | 4 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Nevada | Likely, not settled | Not settled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
| New Hampshire | Likely, not settled | Policy decides | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| New Jersey | Yes | Policy decides | 6 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| New Mexico | Yes | No, courts ruled | 4 years | Pure comparative | $10,000 |
| New York | Limited | Policy decides | 3 years | Pure comparative | $10,000 |
| North Carolina | Yes | Not settled | 3 years | Contributory negligence | $50,000 |
| North Dakota | Limited | Not settled | 6 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Ohio | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Oklahoma | Yes | Policy decides | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Oregon | Likely, not settled | Yes, only if the policy guarantees pre-crash condition | 6 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
| Pennsylvania | Yes | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $5,000 |
| Rhode Island | Likely, not settled | Not settled | 10 years | Pure comparative | $25,000 |
| South Carolina | Yes | No, courts ruled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| South Dakota | Yes | No, courts ruled | 6 years | Slight vs. gross negligence | $25,000 |
| Tennessee | Likely, not settled | No, courts ruled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $25,000 |
| Texas | Likely, not settled | No, courts ruled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Utah | Yes | Not settled | 4 years | Modified comparative, 50% bar | $15,000 |
| Vermont | Yes | Policy decides | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| Virginia | Yes | No, courts ruled | 5 years | Contributory negligence | $25,000 |
| Washington | Yes | Policy decides | 3 years | Pure comparative | $10,000 |
| West Virginia | Limited | Not settled | 2 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $25,000 |
| Wisconsin | Yes | No, courts ruled | 3 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $10,000 |
| Wyoming | Likely, not settled | Not settled | 4 years | Modified comparative, 51% bar | $20,000 |
When a row says "Likely, not settled" or "Not settled," no court decision has been reported, so standard damage rules govern the outcome. "Limited" signals that courts allow the claim in certain situations only, such as repairs that cannot restore a car's original condition. "Policy decides" tells you that the text of your own policy controls what happens.
A car loses resale value after an accident enters its record, even with proper repairs: that drop is diminished value. This material addresses public law; it does not offer legal advice.
Reading the Diminished Value States Table
Diminished value states differ in two ways: whether you may claim from the at-fault driver, and whether you may claim from your own insurer. A Connecticut General Assembly research report notes that most jurisdictions allow the first type of claim but not the second.
Seeking payment from the other driver's insurer. This kind of claim is known as a third-party claim. You bring the claim against the driver at fault, and that driver's insurer typically handles it under the liability portion of the policy. No direct right to sue the insurer comes from it. According to the Connecticut report, the basis for this claim is tort law, which defines how negligence works.
A claim you bring under your own insurance. A diminished value first party claim is what you file using the collision part of your policy. Because this claim arises from contract law, the policy's own terms determine the result. Courts that allow it are in the minority. The best-known example is Georgia, where its Supreme Court decided in State Farm v. Mabry that the word "loss" includes this drop in value.
The reason Oregon looks reversed. The Gonzales v. Farmers (Or. 2008) ruling by the Oregon Supreme Court says that when an insurer fails to bring a car back to its condition before the crash, the policy obligates it to cover the lost value. Searching for decisions on getting money from the other driver, we turned up only one: EAM Advertising Agency v. Helies, a 1998 ruling from the Oregon Court of Appeals. The court signaled it would consider proof of lost value, yet none was presented. That is why the row says "Likely, not settled."
Time limit for filing a lawsuit. The time limit follows the property damage deadline in each state; for car damage, that time limit is the diminished value claim statute of limitations. A chart of the deadlines is kept by Nolo. A shorter window for a first-party claim could be set by your own policy, so read your policy language carefully.
The rule that governs fault. The fault rule decides the result when you share responsibility: states fall into three groups according to Justia's survey. A state that follows contributory negligence bars all recovery if you had any fault. In a pure comparative negligence state, the amount you receive is reduced by the percentage of fault placed on you. Modified comparative negligence rules give you no recovery once your share of fault reaches 50 or 51 percent. Each state chooses its own cutoff point.
Sources for the table
The information in each row is drawn from official state code websites and published appellate court rulings. Where a row carries "Likely, not settled" or "Not settled," we located no statute or appeals court decision that deals with that exact issue. That does not stop you from filing a claim. Should any row appear incorrect to you, please share the source and contact us through the address in the footer.
Anyone may reuse the table under CC BY 4.0 as long as diminishedvaluecalculator.org is credited as the source of the state rules table.
Common Questions From Drivers
Which states let you claim diminished value?
In most states you can bring a claim against the driver who caused the accident. Look up your state's row, then visit the page for that state to see details and the source.
Can you claim diminished value in Georgia?
Yes, you may pursue the at-fault driver and, because of the holding in State Farm v. Mabry (Georgia Supreme Court, 2001), you may also pursue your own insurer. Our Georgia page walks you through the steps.
May an insurer turn down a diminished value claim?
Yes. The loss is yours to prove: send a written demand letter and include your repair records plus an estimate or an appraisal.
Is it worthwhile to file a diminished value claim?
Often yes, provided the car is relatively new, has low mileage and suffered serious damage. It may not be worthwhile when the repair is small. The loss might amount to only a few hundred dollars, while an appraisal usually runs $300 to $600. Start with the free estimate; after that, pick your next move.
Do insurance companies pay for diminished value?
In most cases they do. You can bring the claim when your state permits it and the other driver was at fault. If you file through your own policy, the wording of the policy and your state's rules determine whether you succeed. See how State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, USAA and Liberty Mutual handle these cases.
Questions about your claim? Call to speak with someone who works on diminished value claims.
Call (855) 589-7222