Only in Georgia do the state claim notices from Liberty Mutual speak of diminished value. After a customer submits a crash damage claim in Georgia, the insurer has to check for lost value. So in other places, when does Liberty Mutual pay diminished value? It is paid only where the state allows such claims, and only if Liberty Mutual's own driver was at fault.
Liberty Mutual's Georgia Claims Notice
Liberty Mutual puts out a claims notice for each state. The Georgia notice refers to an order from the state insurance commissioner, issued December 7, 2001. Every insurer was required by the order to look into lost value. That check is part of a customer's regular claim for crash damage to the vehicle.
The notice traces the order back to the case of State Farm v. Mabry. The Supreme Court of Georgia ruled on November 28, 2001 in that case. Its ruling: a car can lose value from physical damage even after it is repaired.
The same notice shares three more useful details. The insurer expects to complete its review within 45 days. Claims for property damage in Georgia have a 4-year deadline, as the notice states. The notice tells you to contact the state's insurance office when you dispute the way it handled the claim.
How to Claim Against a Liberty Mutual Driver
When a Liberty Mutual customer hits you, the claim you make is a third-party claim on that driver's policy. A choice on the online claim form is set up for people who are making a claim against someone the company insures. You will be asked for the insured person's last name along with their policy number. A Safeco-insured driver follows the same path, since Safeco is now part of Liberty Mutual.
A report for the Connecticut General Assembly notes that claims for lost value are allowed by most courts against the at-fault driver. It adds that the person claiming must prove the loss. Check your state on our table of state rules.
Does Liberty Mutual Pay Diminished Value to Its Own Customers?
Outside Georgia, the answer is usually no. Your own policy usually will not pay for lost value, based on the Connecticut report. The words diminished value do not appear in the notice for any other state. Many notices also state that a customer could recover some out-of-pocket costs from the other driver's insurer. That recovery depends on how fault is divided between the two parties.
So if someone hit you and you carry Liberty Mutual, go after the lost value through that driver’s insurer. Also send a written request to your adjuster and read through the loss section of your policy.
How to Push Back on a Low Offer from Liberty Mutual
A common way insurers calculate lost value is the 17c formula, J.D. Power notes. Ask which damage and mileage numbers the adjuster used. Then come back with an appraisal from someone who understands your local market. That appraisal and a brief demand letter should form the foundation of a Liberty Mutual diminished value claim. When the insurer delays, send your complaint to your state's insurance department.

