Lost value answer, past the menu
Call(855) 589-7222

How to Calculate Diminished Value

After a crash, you can find the drop in your car's worth in two different ways. We walk you through each way, step by step, and include an example from real life.

Your 17c figure = the pre-crash value × 10% × the damage multiplier × the mileage multiplier

Calculate it for your car

To learn how to calculate diminished value, all you need is a pen and your phone's calculator. Diminished value is how much less your car sells for once a crash appears on its record. That drop stays even after a good repair. You will work out two separate numbers. The first number is the 17c figure. When you file a claim for the loss, many insurance companies start with this low number. That kind of request is called a claim. The second number is the market range. For your car, it estimates both the smallest and the largest drop in what a buyer would offer. You can also skip the math entirely and let our diminished value calculator handle it.

Driver calculating diminished value with a calculator and the repair invoice

Before You Begin: What Do You Need?

  1. Your car's value just before the crash happened. You can look it up at Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides. J.D. Power, a company that follows the auto market, says you should take this step. Both sites list used car prices.
  2. How badly the car was damaged. You pick one out of five levels. The lowest level applies when only the bumpers or body panels are affected. The outer parts of the car, such as doors and fenders, are called body panels. The highest level is a frame that is severely bent. The frame is the metal skeleton that sits under the car's body.
  3. How many miles were on the car the day of the crash.

You do not need your repair bill for this.

How Is Diminished Value Calculated Under 17c?

Many insurance companies use a formula called 17c to build their first offer. A court case in Georgia gave it that name. The ruling from that case put the calculation in paragraph 17, section C. Two multipliers are applied in sequence to cut the figure down. A multiplier is a number that falls anywhere from 0 to 1. When you apply a multiplier of 1.00, the full amount stays. A multiplier of 0.50 keeps half the amount. A multiplier of 0.00 leaves you with nothing.

  1. First, figure out 10% of what your car was worth before the crash. This amount is the most your 17c figure can ever reach.
  2. Next, go to the first table and pick the row that describes your car’s damage. Take the number from step 1 and multiply it by the figure in the 17c column.
  3. After that, turn to the second table for your mileage. Use the figure from that row and multiply your latest amount by it. What you get is your 17c number.
Your damage answer17c multiplierMarket range (% of value)
Frame badly damaged1.0015% to 30%
Large damage to the frame and many panels0.7510% to 20%
Some damage to the frame and several panels0.505% to 12%
Small frame damage and a few affected panels0.253% to 8%
Panels or bumpers only, frame not touched0.002% to 5%
Your miles answer17c mileage multiplier
Under 20,0001.00
20,000 to 39,9990.80
40,000 to 59,9990.60
60,000 to 79,9990.40
80,000 to 99,9990.20
100,000 or more0.00

When a table shows 0.00, your 17c figure becomes $0. You will see this if your frame was untouched, or if the car has reached 100,000 miles or more. Your car can still lose value even when the result comes out to $0. That is simply how the formula is built. State Farm refused payment for a vehicle with over 100,000 miles because of this rule, according to one court case.

How the Market Range Uses a Diminished Value Percentage

The market range gives a truer picture of what buyers really spend. Each level of damage has a diminished value percentage of its own. The last column of the first table shows it. You multiply your car's pre-accident value by that percentage. This step leaves out the cost of repairs.

  1. Go to the first table and locate your damage level.
  2. Multiply your car's value by the low percentage. The answer is the bottom of your range.
  3. Multiply your car's value by the high percentage. The answer is the top of your range.

Since the calculator rounds answers to the nearest $50, your figures might not line up exactly with its results.

How We Picked the Percentages

No public study assigns a market loss number to each of the five 17c damage levels. We turned to three sources instead.

  • A used-car shopping site, CarGurus, looked at 2 million listings. Forbes reported that vehicles with a crash history had prices set 3% to 12% lower most of the time.
  • A law firm in Utah, Property Damage Pros, keeps appraisers on staff. An appraiser is a trained expert who determines a car’s value. The firm sets its damage percentages this way: dents and bumpers get 2% to 5%, damage with an airbag or several panels gets 5% to 12%, and a bent frame gets 15% to 30%.
  • A different firm, Car Value Law, applies 10% to 20% for medium-level damage.

We picked the smaller figure any time the sources did not agree. Our ranges are therefore on the careful side. The gaps are filled by the two middle levels. The bottom of the CarGurus range is where the 3% to 8% level begins. The 10% to 20% level matches the range the second firm uses.

How to Calculate Diminished Value by Hand

J.D. Power provided this example car. The car, with 45,000 miles on it, was worth $30,000 before the crash. In the accident, the frame got a small bend and a few panels were dented.

This car’s 17c number works out to $450. The market range spans from $900 up to $2,400. So the lowest number in the market range is still twice as high as the 17c figure. Our numbers show that the market range never begins below the 17c amount.

Look at the Calculation for This Car
  1. Begin with 10% of $30,000: that comes to $3,000.
  2. Damage: When the frame damage is small, the 17c multiplier is 0.25; $3,000 multiplied by 0.25 equals $750.
  3. Miles: The multiplier for 45,000 miles is 0.60. Multiply $750 by 0.60 and you arrive at $450, your 17c figure.
  4. Market range: A market loss of 3% to 8% applies to small frame damage. 3% of $30,000 is $900; 8% comes to $2,400. The range is therefore $900 to $2,400.

How Should You Read Your Result?

Each of the two numbers answers a separate question. An insurance company's formula gives you the 17c figure, and that is often its starting point. The market range comes closer to the real drop in what a buyer will pay.

The 17c formula follows strict rules. It never pays anything beyond 10% of the car's value. You receive $0 when the frame was untouched, and $0 after the car reaches 100,000 miles. Still, any car with a crash history draws lower offers from buyers. Carfax, which sells reports on a car’s accident record, states the average price drop is about $500.

A single diminished value formula does not fit every car. Comparing an offer to your repair bill can be useful. The national association for state insurance officials is the NAIC. Its journal published a study showing the loss often runs from about 10% to about 20% of the repair cost. We found no trusted average diminished value settlement, a number that would show a typical insurer payment. For that reason do not treat either figure as a typical payout.

What Is Not Included in the Estimate?

  • This is not an appraisal. We base your diminished value estimate only on the three answers you provide. Nobody looks at your car. For a large claim Kelley Blue Book advises hiring a certified appraiser, an expert with a professional certificate. Our appraisal guide explains when that expense is worth it.
  • Repair quality is not checked. Poor work like mismatched paint can cost you extra money. Our tool does not include that additional loss.
  • The age and brand of your car do not count. Kelley Blue Book notes that a newer car with lower miles stands a better chance of a payment. The Insurance Information Institute, a group from the insurance industry, states that swapping old parts for new ones can sometimes raise an older car's value after repairs.
  • It measures only the drop in what your car would sell for. The cost of repairs is handled by a separate payment. You get the value your car held right before the crash if it was a total loss: that means fixing it was not worthwhile. The Washington state insurance office explains this rule.
  • You will not find an answer here about your own right to file a claim. Your state and who was at fault both decide whether you can. A driver struck by another person can claim this loss in any state except Michigan, says the Insurance Information Institute. You can see the rules that apply in each state in our state rules table. This serves as general information, not as legal advice.

What Steps Can You Take Next?

When your 17c figure lands much lower than your market range, you can point to that gap as a reason to seek more money. A demand letter is a short letter asking the insurance company for a set amount of money. Our demand letter template produces the letter for you. For the insurer’s perspective, see our guide to the 17c formula. Is this your first time? The basics are explained in our guide to what diminished value means.

Questions about your claim? Call to speak with someone who works on diminished value claims.

Call (855) 589-7222