Questions about State Farm diminished value have a longer court record than those involving any other insurer. This type of loss became broadly recognized because of a suit brought against State Farm. When a State Farm driver hits you and your state permits it, State Farm usually pays the lost value under that driver's policy. A State Farm policyholder most often hears no, but residents of Georgia are the exception.
After a Crash Where a State Farm Driver Is at Fault
You submit this as a third-party claim, so the insurer of the other driver is the one you ask for payment. Your car was damaged, and the person responsible for the crash has to pay you for that. In most states that damage covers the lost value too, even when the car has been fixed correctly. Most courts accept claims of this kind, as a research report for the Connecticut General Assembly pointed out. The report also says you must still prove the loss.
Payment comes from the property damage liability part of the driver's policy with State Farm. That coverage pays for damage the driver does to someone else’s property. Rules still differ by state, so begin by checking your state on our table of state rules.
The start of 17c and the State Farm v. Mabry decision
The Supreme Court of Georgia handed down the State Farm v. Mabry decision in 2001. The court held that a car can lose value from being damaged, even when repairs bring back its look and its function. State Farm had to count that loss along with the physical damage, the court said. The Matthiesen, Wickert and Lehrer law firm carried out a survey covering all 50 states. The finding: State Farm was ordered to pay $150 million to cover settlements and fees.
State Farm's own calculation, the 17c formula, came afterward. J.D. Power notes the term was taken from the place it began: paragraph 17, section C. A federal appeals court looked at actual 17c payments later, in Tiller v. State Farm. For one driver the amount was $48.76. According to the drivers, the formula was made to give low numbers. The court did not rule on whether the formula itself was fair.
Will State Farm pay a person who bought its policy?
In most cases, no. A claim you make on your own insurance is classified as a first‑party claim. After repairs, a covered vehicle’s drop in value is excluded from a covered loss, according to State Farm's Ohio auto policy booklet. The details differ from one state to another in these booklets. From your agent, get your own booklet and check the part that defines a loss.
Georgia is the big exception. Because of Mabry, State Farm must account for lost value when a Georgia customer files a claim for vehicle damage. That decision also explains why the 17c method began in Georgia and then spread to other locations.
What to Send to State Farm
Put your request in writing and write the claim number on every page. Hold on to the originals; send copies. A solid file holds these pieces:
- the final repair bill you received, itemized by parts and labor
- pictures of the damage, before any repairs
- a vehicle history report that records the crash
- a market estimate or appraisal that backs up the amount you are requesting
That evidence is what a State Farm diminished value claim rests on. Our free estimate puts the formula number from the insurer next to a market range. Then the fill-in demand letter uses your numbers to build a short letter for printing and sending.
How to Push Back Against a Low Offer from State Farm
Ask the adjuster for an explanation of the offer in writing. If the offer came from 17c, find out what damage figures and what mileage numbers were used. The Tiller case showed that, for a vehicle over 100,000 miles, State Farm set the mileage modifier at 0%. That means the formula can leave a high-mileage car with almost no payout.
Georgia's state insurance office says that relying completely on a single formula may be an error. You can point to the wording from the 2008 Georgia directive. In any state, your best tool is a written appraisal from a person who understands the local market. If the claim gets stuck, you can file a complaint with your state insurance department. Our claim steps walk through what comes next.
State Farm Diminished Value Questions
If a State Farm driver hits me, will the company pay?
Most of the time, yes: your state must allow the claim, and you must be able to show the loss. You file your claim against the driver, and the driver’s State Farm coverage handles the payment.
Does State Farm Pay Diminished Value to Its Own Customers?
The Ohio booklet we reviewed excludes it; no payment is made for a loss in value after a repair. Georgia customers are the exception, thanks to the Mabry ruling.
How do I start a claim with State Farm?
Tell the adjuster handling your open claim that you are also requesting payment for the lost value. Then send your letter and proof, and keep a copy of each item.
