Georgia: The meaning of the two numbers
You receive two numbers. The market range is the amount buyers would probably take off your car's price. The first offer from many insurers comes from a short formula that yields the 17c figure. The 17c formula was first created in Georgia. The formula was designed by State Farm after State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Mabry, a 2001 decision from the Georgia Supreme Court. A Georgia trial court later approved the formula, based on what a federal appeals court opinion stated.
That first offer is not the final answer. Insurers must weigh all relevant facts, and the state never approved any formula, says a 2008 directive by Georgia's insurance commissioner. If your market range is much larger, you can ask for the difference between that range and the 17c figure.
The two 17c multiplier tables
The 17c method begins by taking 10% of your car's worth before the crash. That amount is then multiplied by two numbers called multipliers, each from 0 to 1. Damage is what one multiplier covers. The other accounts for how many miles were on the car.
| Damage to the car | Multiplier |
|---|---|
| Frame or structure badly damaged | 1.00 |
| Large damage to the frame and many panels | 0.75 |
| Some damage to the frame and several panels | 0.50 |
| Small frame damage and a few affected panels | 0.25 |
| Panels or bumpers only, no structural damage | 0.00 |
| Miles at the time of the crash | Multiplier |
|---|---|
| 0 to 19,999 | 1.00 |
| 20,000 to 39,999 | 0.80 |
| 40,000 to 59,999 | 0.60 |
| 60,000 to 79,999 | 0.40 |
| 80,000 to 99,999 | 0.20 |
| 100,000 or more | 0.00 |
A car gets a 17c payment of $0 when it has no frame damage or 100,000 miles or more. Even so, the market range may still point to an actual loss. A complete example is given on the 17c formula page.
Showing the estimate to a Georgia insurer
In Georgia, you are allowed to submit a claim to either insurance company.
- The other driver's insurer. You may ask that company to pay for the lost value together with the repair costs. You have this right because of Myers v. Thornton, a 1997 decision from the Georgia Court of Appeals.
- Your own insurer. When your insurer pays a damage claim for your car, Mabry requires it to look for lost value.
- Your time limit. You get four years to sue, based on Ga. Code § 9-3-31.
- The share of fault that belongs to you. Georgia law says you collect nothing from the other driver's insurer once your portion of the fault reaches 50 percent or higher. This rule does not apply to a claim on your own policy; the policy terms govern instead.
Georgia: is a claim worth filing, and when is it better to skip it?
A claim is usually worth filing for a car that is fairly new, has low mileage and was badly damaged. Kelley Blue Book notes that your odds of getting paid go up when the car is newer and has fewer miles. You have more room in Georgia than in most states, because your own insurer must also consider the loss.
You may find it is not worth your time in these cases:
- A small repair job. A study in the NAIC Journal of Insurance Regulation found that losses are commonly about 10% to 20% of the repair bill. A $2,000 repair might leave you with a loss no higher than $200 to $400.
- The car is old and the mileage is high. Its value may drop only a small amount more.
- A car that was written off as a total loss. There is no repaired vehicle left to suffer a drop in resale value.
- Your fault was 50 percent or more, and you planned to claim against the other driver.
An independent appraisal is a written value report from a car appraiser. The typical cost runs from $300 to $600. Pay for one when the loss you expect is clearly bigger than the fee.
Georgia Diminished Value Claim: 5 Filing Steps
- Get the repair done and keep your records. Hold onto the repair estimate, the final shop bill and any photos of the damage taken before the work was done.
- Gather your figures. Run the free estimate tool. Next, get a vehicle history report, such as Carfax, that shows the crash on the record.
- Hire an appraiser if the loss is large. The appraiser inspects the repaired vehicle and documents how much value was lost. Insurance companies give that report more weight than they give a table.
- Put your demand in writing. Deliver it to the insurer covering the other driver. It can also be sent to your own insurer under Mabry. Include your estimate, the repair invoice, photos, the vehicle history report and your appraisal when you have one. A short note stating the sum you want: our demand letter has a field for your number. Keep a copy for yourself.
- Push back when the offer is too low. Reply in writing and cite the 2008 directive. If the claim stalls, file a complaint with the Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire. You may also take a claim below $15,000 to magistrate court. You must file a lawsuit within four years.
