Texas: what the pair of figures tells you
There are two numbers to understand. The market range tells you what buyers would probably subtract from the price of your car. The 17c figure comes from a short formula that a lot of insurers rely on to make their opening offer. Texas itself gives you no calculation method. In Bulletin B-0027-00, the Texas Department of Insurance informed insurers that they may still have to pay the other driver for lost market value after a complete repair. The bulletin does not give you a method for working out that loss. Treat the adjuster's number as a place to start, and return with a market range of your own.
A 50-state survey from the law firm Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer reviewed the rules of every state. It did not find a Texas court ruling that explicitly allows you to claim diminished value from the driver at fault. That means proof matters. A market estimate supported by an independent appraisal outweighs any table. You will find both multiplier tables on the 17c formula page. The 17c formula uses those values for its multiplication.
Presenting Your Estimate to an Insurer in Texas
Direct your claim to the insurer of the driver who caused the accident.
- Do not use your own collision coverage. A 2003 decision from the Texas Supreme Court, in American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Co. v. Schaefer, the only thing your own collision policy covers is the repair bill. The lost value is not covered.
- When the other driver had too little insurance, or had none at all. The lost value may be owed by your uninsured or underinsured motorist protection, the bulletin states.
- The time you have to act. You have two years to file a lawsuit under Section 16.003 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code.
- The share of fault that belongs to you. Texas law bars any payment from the other driver once your responsibility reaches 51 percent.
Should You File a Claim in Texas, and When Does It Not Make Sense?
A claim is often worthwhile when the other driver was at fault, your car is fairly new, has low miles and suffered actual damage. Kelley Blue Book notes that a newer car and fewer miles raise your chance of getting paid.
A claim may not be worth the effort in a few situations:
- A small repair job. A study in the NAIC Journal of Insurance Regulation found the loss often runs about 10% to 20% of the cost of repairs. A $2,000 repair could leave you with only $200 to $400 in lost value.
- The car is old and the mileage is high. Almost no value may be left for the car to lose.
- A car that was written off as a total loss. There is no repaired vehicle left that could suffer a loss in resale value.
- You caused the accident. Only the repair is covered by your own collision policy.
An independent appraisal generally costs between $300 and $600. A car appraiser prepares this report on what the vehicle is worth. Have one done if the loss you expect is clearly larger than that price.
5 Steps to File Your Texas Diminished Value Claim
- Finish all repairs and hold on to every record. Keep the estimate, the final repair invoice and photos of the damage from before the work started.
- Gather your figures. First finish the free estimate; then request a Carfax or a similar vehicle history report that documents the crash.
- Hire an appraiser when the loss is substantial. After repairs are complete, an appraiser inspects the car and notes how much its value has fallen. Since no court rule in Texas fixes a dollar amount, the report is your strongest piece of evidence.
- Put what you are asking for into a written demand. Deliver it to the at‑fault driver’s insurer; if that driver carried no insurance, send it to your uninsured motorist coverage. Attach the repair bill, the photos, the estimate, a vehicle history report and, if you have it, an appraisal. You can put your own dollar amount into our short demand letter. Keep a copy of that letter for yourself.
- When the offer comes back too low, challenge it. Reply in writing and cite Bulletin B-0027-00. If the claim stalls, file a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance or bring the matter to a justice court. That Texas small claims court hears cases for amounts up to $20,000. A lawsuit must be started within two years.
